He wanted to put $60,000 away for himself this year. A friend told him a SEP IRA was the easy way to do it (example numbers).
He runs an HVAC company with nine technicians. His W-2 salary is $300,000, so a 20% SEP contribution gets him to $60,000. Simple.
Then he read the rules. A SEP has to give every eligible employee the same percentage. Nine technicians averaging $60,000 a year at 20% is another $108,000. To save $60,000 for himself, the company would put in $168,000.
The SEP was not the wrong idea. It was the wrong plan for a company with a crew. And that is the part most retirement advice skips, because most of it is written for freelancers with no employees.
The Solo 401(k) Is Not an Option Once You Have a Crew
Search for the best retirement plan for a small business owner and the solo 401(k) comes up first. It has high limits, it is cheap to run, and it is built for a business with no employees other than the owner and a spouse.
That last part is the catch. Once you have employees who meet the plan’s eligibility rules, a solo 401(k) stops being a solo plan. Almost every contractor we talk to has a crew, so for them the real choice is between three plans: a SEP IRA, a SIMPLE IRA and a 401(k).
The Three Plans Side by Side
| SEP IRA | SIMPLE IRA | 401(k), including safe harbor | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who puts money in | Only the company | Employees, plus a required company match or contribution | Employees, plus company contributions |
| 2026 limit per person | 25% of pay, up to $72,000 | $17,000 from the employee, plus catch-up | $24,500 from the employee, plus catch-up; up to $72,000 total with company money |
| What the company must give employees | The same percentage it gives the owner | A 3% match or a 2% contribution for everyone | Depends on the design; a safe harbor plan has a set minimum |
| Cost to run | Very low | Low | Moderate to higher |
| Deadline to open it for 2026 | Your tax return due date, including extensions | October 1, 2026 (already passed for a new plan) | Employee deferrals need the plan in place first |
| Best fit | Owner-only or very small teams | Up to 100 employees who should save too | Owners who want to save the most and offer a real benefit |
Catch-up contributions add room for people 50 and older: $8,000 in a 401(k) and $4,000 in a SIMPLE IRA for 2026, with higher amounts for ages 60 to 63.
SEP IRA: Easy to Open, Expensive to Share
A SEP IRA is the simplest plan to start. There is no annual testing, the paperwork is short, and the company decides each year whether to contribute at all.
The trade-off is in one rule: the company has to contribute equally for all eligible employees. If the owner gets 20% of pay, every eligible employee gets 20% of theirs. An eligible employee is generally someone who is at least 21, has worked for you in at least 3 of the last 5 years and earned at least a minimum amount.
In a crew where most people have been with you three years or more, a SEP turns into a company-wide profit-sharing check. That can be a great retention tool if you want it. It is an expensive surprise if you only wanted to save for yourself.
When a SEP fits a contractor:
- You have no employees yet, or only short-tenure ones who are not eligible.
- You want to decide the contribution after the year ends, when you know your profit.
- You are comfortable giving the same percentage to everyone who qualifies.
SIMPLE IRA: The Crew Saves, You Match
A SIMPLE IRA flips the model. Employees choose how much of their own pay to put in, up to $17,000 in 2026. The company then does one of two things for the year:
- Matches each employee’s contributions dollar for dollar, up to 3% of their pay, or
- Contributes 2% of pay for every eligible employee, whether they contribute or not.
For a company where many employees will not contribute, the 3% match usually costs less. For a company that wants a predictable number, the 2% contribution is easier to budget.
Two rules matter for contractors. A SIMPLE IRA is for employers with generally 100 or fewer employees, and it has to be the only retirement plan the company has. The other rule is timing: a new SIMPLE IRA can be set up effective any date from January 1 through October 1 of a year. For 2026, that window has closed. For 2027, the plan can start January 1.
The SIMPLE IRA works well for a company that wants a real benefit for the crew at a low cost. Its weakness is the owner’s ceiling: $17,000 plus the match and catch-up is much less than a 401(k) allows.
401(k) and Safe Harbor 401(k): The Most Room, the Most Moving Parts
A 401(k) gives the owner the most room. In 2026, an owner can defer up to $24,500 of salary, plus catch-up, and the company can add profit-sharing on top, up to $72,000 per person in total.
The cost is complexity. A traditional 401(k) has to pass annual nondiscrimination tests that compare what owners and higher earners put in with what everyone else puts in. In a contracting company where the owner saves a lot and most of the crew saves little, those tests can fail, and the fix is often refunding part of the owner’s contributions.
A safe harbor 401(k) solves that. The company commits to a minimum contribution for employees, which is fully vested when it is made, and in exchange the plan skips the main testing. The owner can then defer the full amount without worrying about how much the crew saves.
The timing rule to know now: employees must receive a written safe harbor notice at least 30 days and not more than 90 days before the plan year starts. For a plan year that starts January 1, 2027, that notice has to go out in early December. That is why November is the month to decide.
What You Can Still Do for 2026, and What Has to Wait for 2027
Here is where the calendar puts each option today:
- SEP IRA for 2026: still possible. A SEP can be set up and funded as late as your business tax return’s due date, including extensions.
- SIMPLE IRA for 2026: closed for a new plan, because the October 1 date has passed. It can start on January 1, 2027.
- 401(k) employee deferrals for 2026: in general, salary deferrals cannot be made for pay that has already been paid, so a plan opened now does little for 2026 deferrals. Some employer-only contributions can still count for 2026 depending on the plan and when it is adopted. That is a question to ask with your numbers in front of you.
- 401(k) or safe harbor 401(k) for 2027: decide in November so the notice can go out in early December and payroll is ready on January 1.
So the honest message for most contractors with a crew is not “November is your last chance for 2026.” It is: a SEP can still cover 2026, and November is when you choose the plan for 2027.
The Government Will Help Pay to Start One
If you do not have a plan today, the tax code helps pay for a new one. Employers with 50 or fewer qualifying employees can claim a credit for 100% of eligible startup costs, up to $5,000 a year for three years. Employers with 51 to 100 employees can claim 50%.
There is also a credit for employer contributions to many new plans, up to $1,000 per employee in the first years and phasing down after that, and a separate $500 a year for three years if the plan includes automatic enrollment. Those credits change the math: a plan that looked too expensive to run may cost much less than you think in its first years.
How to Choose
A short way to think about it:
- No employees, or none eligible yet: a SEP IRA, or a solo 401(k) while you have no crew.
- A crew, a tight budget and a goal of giving people a benefit: a SIMPLE IRA starting January 1.
- A crew, high owner income and a goal of saving the most: a safe harbor 401(k), possibly with profit-sharing.
- A long-tenured crew and a SEP already in place: run the numbers on what the equal-percentage rule costs before this year’s contribution.
The right plan is the one where what you put in for yourself and what you put in for your crew both make sense for your profit. That is a modeled decision, and it belongs in your year-end tax plan next to equipment purchases like Section 179 and your S corp salary, because all three draw on the same profit and the same deadlines.
Where to Start
A retirement plan is one of the biggest tax decisions an owner can still make this year, and it is part of tax planning, not tax filing. The free Contractor Tax Savings Plan Assessment looks at where your tax plan stands before the year closes. Israel Diaz, an IRS Enrolled Agent (a federal credential earned by exam), uses it to see which moves are still open for you.
Take the free Contractor Tax Savings Plan Assessment →
This article is general information, not tax or retirement plan advice for your specific situation. Plan rules, deadlines and credits depend on your company, your employees and your numbers.




